Complaints are aimed both at the scarcity of decent comparative legal tax scholarship, and at the lack of a theoretical foundation for the study of comparative tax law. The most wellknown text book in comparative tax law, in general, is thourony, comparative tax law thuronyi. The discursive failure in comparative tax law what weve got here is. Thuronyi et al comparative tax law, 2016 posits 4 reasons. A comparative approach, second edition by alan schenk, victor thuronyi, and wei cui. Comparative tax law 2nd edition by victor thuronyi, kim brooks, borbala kolozs is the best of its kind. On adopting a comparative approach to reforming the u. Thuronyi, tax law design and drafting volume 2 international monetary fund. The busy reader will welcome the compact nature of this work, which is shorter than the first edition and can be read in a weekend if one skips footnotes. David duff, tim edgar, glenn feltham, and alan macnaughton victor thuronyi, comparative tax law the hague. Click download or read online button to get kanga and palkhivala s the law and practice of income tax book now. Wei cui is an associate professor in the faculty of law at the university of british columbia.
Comparative tax law, second edition wolters kluwer legal. Buy comparative tax law 2nd ed, edited by victor thuronyi, kim brooks, borbala kolozs, isbn 9789041167194, published by kluwer law international from. Although the details of tax law are literally endless, differing not only from jurisdiction to jurisdiction but from day to day, shared structures and currents exist across tax systems that can be learned and understood with relative ease. Comparative tax law by victor thuronyi, kim brooks. Hermann hesse ltd value added tax a comparative approach cambridge tax law series 2nd edition by alan schenk author visit amazons alan schenk page. Request pdf comparative tax law this book provides an. An introduction to a broad range of issues in comparative tax law. Is mediation the panacea to the profusion of tax disputes. On 3 october 2009, a conference on comparative tax law in theory and practice took place at the university of michigan law school. Tax law design and drafting, volume 1 international monetary fund. Comparative tax law engels door victor thuronyi, kim brooks.
Cambridge core comparative law value added tax by alan schenk. Tax law design and drafting, table of contents for volume 1 and 2. Thuronyi, comparative tax law at 60 kluwer law international 2003. Tax law design and drafting, table of contents for volume. At the first round table, hugh ault, brian arnold, and victor thuronyi discussed the practical implications of comparative tax law. Elgar encyclopedia of comparative law, second edition. Legislative reform proposals to address aggressive. Pdf comparative tax law download full pdf book download. The literature on comparative tax law is substantial, even though it represents only a small portion of the tax law literature. Jan 29, 2020 for purposes of this research guide, foreign tax law refers to tax legislation enacted in jurisdictions outside the u.
Although the details of tax law are literally endlessdiffering not only from jurisdiction to jurisdiction but also from daytoday changes in the working of the systemstructures and patterns exist across tax systems that can be understood with. Comparative tax law victor thuronyi, kim brooks, borbala kolozs on. Edited by victor thuronyi, this book offers an introduction to a broad range of issues in comparative tax law and is based on comparative discussion of the tax laws of. Comparative studies of national law in the eu harmonized vat. It is based on comparative discussion of the tax laws of developed countries. Although the details of tax law are literally endless, differing not o.
Furthermore, it can be used to add structure to the field of tax law, which can be used in further research. Isbn 9781107042988 hardback isbn 9781107617629 paperback 1. Thuronyi, comparattve tax law, supra note 2, at 114. Thuronyi victor, comparative tax law, kluwer law international, 2003.
Oct 31, 2012 comparative law is increasingly integrated into law itself, as a fundamental technique and means of support. Comparative studies of national law in the eu harmonized. Kluwer law international, 2003, 373 pages, isbn 9041199233 it is not entirely unfair to suggest that much of the existing comparative work in tax law is of limited interest or even usefulness. January 2017 kim brooks the new millennium has inspired renewed interest in comparative law generally and comparative tax law in particular, with practitioners and scholars rapidly building the literature that defines the modern field. Comparative tax law edition 2 by victor thuronyi, kim. Besides, comparative tax law can help gain an understanding of the legal context. African journal of international and comparative law.
Legislative reform proposals to address aggressive transfer. Author thuronyi, victor subjects taxation law and legislation comparative law. The comparative presentation of this volume offers an analysis of policy issues relating to tax structure and tax base as well as insights into how cases arising out of vat disputes. General information course name comparative tax law with focus on slovak tax law ects credits 5 semester winter aims the aim of the course is to provide students with basic knowledge of slovak tax system and. Comparative tax law by victor thuronyi, 9789041167194, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Although the details of tax law are literally endlessdiffering not only from jurisdiction to jurisdiction but also from daytoday changes in the working of the systemstructures and patterns exist across tax systems that can be understood. Kluwer law international, 2003, 373 pages, isbn 9041199233.
Comparative tax law engels door victor thuronyi, kim brooks, borbala kolozs onze prijs. This book integrates legal, economic, and administrative materials about the value added tax vat to present the only comparative approach to the study of vat law. It also serves as a resource for tax practitioners and government officials that must grapple with issues under their vat or their prospective vat. A basic knowledge of comparative tax law is essential to understanding taxation. Volume i covers general issues, some special topics, and major. Most of it is descriptive or, even if analytical, has a singlecountry focus. Comparative tax law kindle edition by victor thuronyi, kim. He is the author of comparative tax law 2003 and numerous articles and book chapters on tax law and policy, and he is the editor of and a contributing author to tax law. Oct 31, 2012 the literature on comparative tax law is substantial, even though it represents only a small portion of the tax law literature. The first session discussed the theory of comparative tax law. The most wellknown text book in comparative tax law, in general, is thourony, comparative tax law thuronyi 2003. Summary although the details of tax law are literally endless, differing not only from jurisdiction to jurisdiction but from day to day, shared structures and currents exist across tax systems that can be. Victor thuronyi is the author of comparative tax law 5. Introduction the comparative study of tax law is not strictly theoretically oriented.
Kanga and palkhivala s the law and practice of income tax. Comparative tax law engels door victor thuronyi, kim. Victor thuronyi comparative tax law the tax journal. Use the free adobe acrobat reader to view this pdf file. The argument has thus already been made that comparative law should disappear as an autonomous subject reimann, 1996 or at least be seen as an integral dimension of all forms of legal endeavour glenn, 1999.
Comparative tax law victor thuronyi ff kluwer law international the hague london new york. For purposes of this research guide, foreign tax law refers to tax legislation enacted in jurisdictions outside the u. Comparative tax law kindle edition by thuronyi, victor. The comparative presentation of this volume offers an analysis of policy issues relating to tax structure and tax base as well as insights into how cases arising out of vat disputes have been resolved. This classification between public and private law illustrates the differences in the legal relationship. Law, penn state assaf likhovski, associate professor, tel aviv university faculty of law and visiting professor, ucla law school michael livingston, professor, rutgers school of law camden comparative tax law. International monetary fund imf this book provides an introduction to the core common knowledge that any wellinformed tax lawyer should have about comparative tax law in our times. Theory, methods and agenda for research carlo garbarino professor of taxation, bocconi university, milan. It was organized by reuven aviyonah professor, university of michigan law school and mathias reimann editor, american journal of comparative law and professor, university of michigan law school, and was attended by hugh ault professor of law, boston college. This work presents a comparative analysis of some of the structural and design issues which are involved in mature income tax systems. The most common is private law and public law see v.
Comparative law and professor, university of michigan law school reuven aviyonah, professor, university of michigan law school morning session. Victor thuronyi, senior counsel, international monetary. Free pdf versions of these texts will be available on the course materials section of the my. Carlo garbarino draftoctober 30, 2007 an evolutionary and structural approach to comparative taxation. He is the author of comparative tax law 2003 and numerous articles and book chapters on tax law and policy, and he is the editor of and a contributing author to tax law design and drafting2000. The title of this book is comparative tax law and it was written by victor thuronyi, kim brooks, borbala kolozs.
This book, now in an updated new edition, focuses on these essential patterns. It presents practical models and guidelines for drafting tax legislation that can be used by officials of developing and transition countries. It was organized by reuven aviyonah professor, university of michigan law school and mathias reimann editor, american journal of comparative law and professor, university of michigan law school, and was attended by hugh ault professor of law. Tax formants, operative rules and tax transplants c. Incorporating comparative and international law into first year property classes 2004 54 journal of legal education 188. In the field of comparative vat law, little is written about theory and methodology. Value added tax a comparative approach cambridge tax law series ebook format jan 30, 2020 pdf book by. Pdf tax law design and drafting individual income tax. Edited by victor thuronyi, this book offers an introduction to a broad range of issues in comparative tax law and is based on comparative discussion of the tax laws of developed countries. Countries selected for the study are australia, canada, france, germany, japan, the netherlands, sweden, the united kingdom and the united states. Comparative tax law in theory and practice request pdf. The development of the discipline of comparative tax law.
Gordon 18 international aspects of income tax richard vann 19 taxation of legal persons and their owners. Comparative tax law, now presented in an updated new edition, focuses on the essential patterns of tax law in different jurisdictions across the globe. Carlo garbarino draftoctober 30, 2007 theory, methods. A number of tax scholars argue that comparative tax research is the application of the comparative law in the field of taxation see, e. On october 3, 2009, a conference on comparative tax law in theory and practice took place at the university of michigan law school, and the proceedings are summarized in this paper. It highlights basic structural differences in tax law across countries, both on a general level and for specific taxes. Whether youve loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them. The development of the discipline of comparative tax law draft. Read value added tax a comparative approach cambridge. Pdf versions of these texts will be available on the course materials section of the my. Such material might not properly be considered as comparative, although it furnishes a good basis for comparative study.
He is the author of comparative tax law 2003 and numerous articles and book chapters on tax law and policy, and he is the editor of and a contributing author to tax law design and drafting 2000. Methods and agenda for research carlo garbarino professor of taxation, bocconi university, milan 1. Tax comparatists tend to bemoan the grim status of their chosen field. General information course name comparative tax law with focus on slovak tax law ects credits 5 semester winter aims the aim of the course is to provide students with basic knowledge of slovak tax. This site is like a library, use search box in the. This book, however, focusesmuch more on describing different tax systems of the world, than with methodological issues. It is not entirely unfair to suggest that much of the existing comparative work in tax law is of limited interest or even usefulness.
1004 772 487 536 319 1138 1030 1420 45 308 1322 1274 769 98 1665 121 1003 23 1070 231 361 48 893 1023 118 599 1163 371 1012 1257 59 1481 1488 1322 1420 321 1043 800 346